The Submarine Cables
Israel's Physical Internet Infrastructure Position
The Geography
Open any map. Draw a line from London to Mumbai. The shortest path passes through the Mediterranean Sea, and at the eastern end of that sea, the line must choose: south through the Suez Canal and Egypt, or northeast through a 12-kilometer strip of land between the Mediterranean and the Red Sea.
That strip of land is Israel. Specifically: the Negev desert, terminating at the port city of Eilat on the Gulf of Aqaba.
This is not metaphor. This is physics. Submarine fiber-optic cables connecting Europe to Asia must physically transit one of three routes:
Single chokepoint. Political instability. Houthi attacks on shipping (2024). All existing cables crowded into one corridor.
12 km overland. Stable government. Google chose this for the highest-capacity cable ever built.
+12,000 km. +60ms latency. Economically unviable for primary routes.
Google chose Route B.
Submarine Cable Inventory
Six major submarine cable systems land in Israel, connecting the country to Europe, Africa, and Asia:
LEV Cable System
Italy (Sicily) โ Cyprus โ Israel (Tel Aviv). 2,600 km, 2 fiber pairs, 20 Gbit/s. Ring topology. Israel's first modern submarine cable. Now backup to MedNautilus.
MedNautilus
Italy โ Greece โ Turkey โ Cyprus โ Israel (Tel Aviv + Haifa). 5,729 km, 6 fiber pairs, 3.84 Tb/s. Owned by Telecom Italia. Gave Italy a monopoly on Israeli international connectivity for 8 years.
JONAH (Bezeq International Optical System)
Tel Aviv โ Bari, Italy. 2,300 km, 12.8 Tb/s. Fully owned by Bezeq โ first Israeli-owned international submarine cable. Broke Telecom Italia's monopoly. Extended via Interoute to European cities.
Tamares Telecom Cable
Israel โ Cyprus โ France. 42 Tb/s. Owner: Tamares Group (Poju Zabludowicz โ Finnish-Israeli billionaire, arms dealer background). Second independent route breaking Italian monopoly.
Blue-Raman (Google)
France โ Italy โ Greece โ Israel โ Jordan โ Saudi Arabia โ Djibouti โ Oman โ India. 218 Tb/s (upgradable to 400 Tb/s). 16 fiber pairs. HIGHEST CAPACITY CABLE LINKING EUROPE TO ASIA. Segments fuse underground north of Eilat.
Quantum Cable + EuroAsia Interconnector
Cyprus โ Italy โ France โ Spain. 7,700 km, 200 Tb/s. To be laid alongside the โฌ2.5B EuroAsia electricity interconnector (Israel-Cyprus-Greece). Israel becomes both data and power hub.
Blue-Raman: The Egypt Bypass
Google's Blue-Raman cable system is not merely large. It is paradigm-shifting.
The cable consists of two segments that meet on Israeli soil:
- BLUE: France โ Italy โ Greece โ Israel (Mediterranean segment)
- RAMAN: Israel โ Jordan โ Saudi Arabia โ Djibouti โ Oman โ India (Red Sea/Indian Ocean segment)
Both segments fuse at an underground interconnection point north of Eilat in southern Israel. The cable physically transitions from sea to land, crosses Israeli territory, and returns to sea on the Red Sea side.
Why Israel? Wikipedia states explicitly: the cable was designed to avoid Egypt, which is "widely regarded as a chokepoint for Internet connectivity between Europe and Asia." Google's engineers chose a 12-km overland crossing through Israeli desert rather than route through Egyptian waters where 16+ existing cables already concentrate.
At 218 Tb/s (upgradable to 400 Tb/s using space-division multiplexing), Blue-Raman carries more capacity than all other cables landing in Israel combined. It is the single largest data pipe connecting Europe to Asia.
And it transits Israeli sovereign territory.
The Abraham Accords Connection
Blue-Raman's route through Jordan and Saudi Arabia was enabled by the normalization of Israel-Gulf state relations. The 2020 Abraham Accords (Israel-UAE-Bahrain) and the evolving Israel-Saudi relationship created the diplomatic conditions for a cable to physically cross these countries.
The Accords are typically discussed as diplomatic achievements. In infrastructure terms, they are cable routing agreements. Israel transforms from a dead-end on the eastern Mediterranean coast into a hub connecting Europe to the entire Arabian Peninsula and Indian subcontinent.
JONAH: The First Israeli-Owned International Cable
Until 2012, all of Israel's international submarine cable connectivity was owned by foreign entities โ primarily Telecom Italia through MedNautilus. Israel was a customer of its own internet backbone.
Then Bezeq International built JONAH (Bezeq International Optical System): a 2,300 km cable from Tel Aviv to Bari, Italy, with 12.8 Tb/s capacity using Alcatel-Lucent submarine networking technology. Extended via Interoute's terrestrial network to London, Frankfurt, Amsterdam, Paris, and other European hubs.
Significance: JONAH is fully owned by an Israeli company. No foreign cooperation is required to access the traffic. No warrant to a Telecom Italia subsidiary. No international legal framework. Israeli sovereignty over its own international cable.
The same year, Tamares Telecom (owned by Finnish-Israeli billionaire Poju Zabludowicz) launched a second independent cable to France. In one year, Israel went from one foreign-owned cable system to three independent routes โ two Israeli-owned.
Bezeq: The Monopoly and the Corruption
Bezeq is Israel's dominant telecommunications company โ founded in 1984 as a government monopoly, privatized in 2005 when a consortium led by Apax Partners, Haim Saban, and the Arkin family paid $972 million for 30% of the company.
In 2010, B Communications (owned by Shaul Elovitch's Eurocom Group) acquired controlling interest for $1.75 billion. Elovitch subsequently became central to Case 4000 โ the Netanyahu corruption investigation alleging the Prime Minister provided regulatory favors to Bezeq in exchange for favorable coverage on Elovitch's Walla! news site.
The pattern: He who controls the telecom controls the intelligence. This is not conspiracy โ it is the explicit content of Case 4000. The question of who owns Bezeq is simultaneously the question of who controls Israel's internet infrastructure, who has access to JONAH cable traffic, and who benefits from regulatory decisions about telecommunications.
Bezeq's subsidiary, Bezeq International, operates international services including the JONAH cable. The company is listed on the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange (TA-35 Index) and was included in the UN database of companies operating in illegal Israeli settlements (2020).
Urim SIGINT Base
In the Negev desert, approximately 30 kilometers from Beersheba and near kibbutz Urim, sits one of the world's most significant signals intelligence facilities.
The Urim SIGINT Base consists of rows of satellite dishes that intercept:
- Phone calls across the Middle East, Europe, Africa, and Asia
- Emails and digital communications
- Maritime shipping communications (Inmarsat)
- Satellite communications (originally Intelsat, expanded over decades)
Le Monde Diplomatique (September 2010): Urim is "among the most important intelligence gathering sites in the world."
Duncan Campbell (investigative journalist, exposed ECHELON): The facility is "akin to the UK-USA Echelon satellite interception ground stations."
Wikipedia: Detected keywords and phone numbers are transferred to Unit 8200 headquarters at Herzliya for analysis.
Consider the geography: Urim sits in the same Negev desert where Blue-Raman's two cable segments fuse underground. The SIGINT base and the cable interconnection point share the same region. Satellite interception and cable interception converge in the same physical space.
The Snowden Revelations
On September 11, 2013, The Guardian published a leaked document revealing the NSA's intelligence sharing relationship with Israel's Unit 8200 (ISNU โ Israeli SIGINT National Unit).
Key findings from the 2009 Memorandum of Understanding:
- NSA shares raw, unfiltered signals intelligence with ISNU
- Data is NOT pre-filtered to remove US citizen communications
- The roots of the arrangement go back to 1968 (LBJ-Eshkol agreement)
- From late 1990s-2007, the relationship "tilted heavily in favor of Israeli security concerns"
- NSA partners with both Unit 8200 AND Mossad
James Bamford (NYT) reported that Snowden told him the transferred data contained "communications โ email as well as phone calls โ of countless Arab- and Palestinian-Americans whose relatives in Israel and the Palestinian territories could become targets based on the communications."
Additional Snowden Revelations
- A 2008 NSA document ranked Israel as the "third most aggressive intelligence service against the US"
- The "Gladiator" proposal (2003-2004): Israel proposed a partnership where the US would pay "hundreds of millions" to fund Israeli intelligence activities. Documents contain "receipts for $500,000 in cash payments to Israeli officials for unspecified purposes"
- US/UK intelligence hacked Israeli drone feeds to monitor Gaza operations and potential Iran strike
- The $52.6 billion intelligence "black budget" confirms US counter-intelligence targets Israel
The relationship is simultaneously collaborative (raw intelligence sharing) and adversarial (mutual espionage). Israel is both partner and target โ receiving raw NSA cable intercepts while being the "third most aggressive" spy against the US.
GCHQ Tempora: The Comparison Model
If there is any doubt that intelligence agencies tap submarine cables, GCHQ's Tempora program eliminates it.
Tempora (operational since late 2011) intercepts internet traffic directly from fiber-optic backbone cables landing in the UK. The program:
- Buffers "most Internet communications that are extracted from fibre-optic cables"
- Places intercepts at landing stations with "the knowledge of companies owning either the cables or landing stations"
- Makes no distinction between citizens and suspects
- Required secret agreements with commercial "intercept partners"
- Companies forbidden to reveal warrants; can be compelled to comply
- By May 2012: 300 GCHQ + 250 NSA analysts sorting intercepted data
The NSA's own programs (FAIRVIEW, BLARNEY, STORMBREW, OAKSTAR) perform the same function on US soil and overseas โ "collection of communications on fiber cables and infrastructure as data flows past."
The logical conclusion: If GCHQ taps cables at UK landing stations, and NSA taps cables at US landing stations and overseas, and NSA shares raw intercepts with Israel, and Unit 8200 explicitly "taps undersea cables" (Wikipedia) โ then the 6+ submarine cables landing in Israel are tapped. This is not speculation. It is the standard operating procedure of every SIGINT agency with physical cable access.
The Complete Stack
This is the sixth letter in "The Invisible Nation" series. Each letter has documented one layer of Israeli cyber infrastructure. Together, they form a picture unlike any other nation:
6+ submarine cables. Blue-Raman (218-400 Tb/s) routes through Israeli territory. JONAH fully Israeli-owned. Land bridge position between Europe and Asia.
Confirmed cable-tapping. Urim base comparable to Echelon. Raw NSA data since 1968. Gulfstream surveillance jets. Embassy listening posts.
034B: Kamatera/Mishayev โ 37 IPs, 930 hits, registered in SC/US/DE/NL. Never "Israel."
034C: 4 of top 10 VPNs + 2 review sites. Unit 8200 co-founder. $1.6B takeout. Controls the privacy tools.
034D: Unit 8200 โ NSO ($2B), Check Point ($20B), Wiz ($12B), Cybereason. Military SIGINT training โ commercial offensive.
034E: 400M IPs. SDK in 250M smart TVs. Residential proxy network. See any IP, from any location.
No other nation simultaneously operates at:
- Physical cable layer (land bridge + owned cable)
- SIGINT layer (cable-tapping + satellite + embassy posts)
- Cloud layer (offshore-registered providers)
- VPN layer (controls the privacy tools people use to hide)
- Application layer (residential proxy network, offensive tools)
- Talent layer (military intelligence โ commercial pipeline)
- Intelligence sharing layer (raw NSA feed + own collection)
And all of this while appearing in global threat intelligence databases with 7 IPs and zero honeypot hits (034A).
Investigative Q&A
Q: Why did Google route the world's highest-capacity Europe-Asia cable through Israel specifically?
A: Google's stated reason is avoiding Egypt as a chokepoint. Egypt has 16+ cables concentrated in one corridor, subject to anchor damage, political instability, and โ since 2024 โ active Houthi attacks on shipping in the Red Sea approach. The Eilat land bridge offers a geographically separate route. But this also means Google's most important cable physically transits territory controlled by a state with confirmed cable-tapping capability.
Q: Does Israel actually tap these cables?
A: Wikipedia states Unit 8200 "taps undersea cables." GCHQ does it (Tempora). NSA does it (Upstream Collection). Both share raw intercepts with Israel. The question is not WHETHER Israel taps cables โ it is documented โ but WHICH cables and HOW MUCH is processed.
Q: Does Google know its Blue-Raman cable transits a SIGINT-capable state?
A: Google employs some of the world's most sophisticated network engineers. The SIGINT capabilities of Unit 8200 are publicly documented. The Snowden revelations were global news. Google made this routing decision with full knowledge. The relevant question is what agreements โ public or secret โ govern the cable's transit through Israeli territory.
Q: What is the legal framework for cable interception in Israel?
A: Israel's communications interception laws (Wiretapping Law 1979, amended) are classified in their military intelligence applications. Unlike GCHQ (governed by Investigatory Powers Act 2016) or NSA (FISA), there is no public legal framework governing Unit 8200's cable-tapping operations. The oversight mechanism, if any exists, is not public.
Q: How does this compare to China's approach?
A: China builds the cloud and tolerates the attack (031 series โ thousands of IPs, visible botnets, detectable patterns). Israel builds the infrastructure and sells the weapon. China appears in threat databases with 1,000+ IPs. Israel appears with 7. The sophistication ceiling is categorically different.
Q: Is Blue-Raman's routing through Israel a coincidence or a strategic choice?
A: Consider: The cable's overland fusion point is in the Negev โ the same desert region as the Urim SIGINT base. The Abraham Accords enabled the Raman segment's route through Jordan and Saudi Arabia. Israel's diplomatic normalization with Gulf states is simultaneously a physical infrastructure routing agreement. Diplomacy and data cables converge in the same narrow strip of land.
Q: Who ultimately controls what flows through Israel?
A: Layer by layer: Physical cables (Bezeq owns JONAH, Google transits Blue-Raman through Israeli soil). Intelligence (Unit 8200 + Urim base + raw NSA feed). Cloud (Kamatera/Mishayev offshore-registered). VPN (Kape owns the privacy tools). Proxy (Bright Data sees residential traffic globally). And the legal framework? Classified. Oversight? Non-public. Public accountability? Seven IPs in a global database. The control architecture exists at every layer, and the oversight architecture exists at none.
Q: What does the "third most aggressive intelligence service against the US" gain by sitting on the US's primary cable route to Asia?
A: The 2008 NSA document calling Israel the "third most aggressive" intelligence adversary of the United States was written BEFORE Blue-Raman was planned, BEFORE the Abraham Accords, BEFORE Israel's cables grew from ~4 Tb/s to ~400 Tb/s capacity. Whatever the relationship was in 2008, the physical infrastructure position has increased by two orders of magnitude since then.
Series Cross-References
- 034A โ The Empty Column: The statistical anomaly โ 7 IPs, 0 hits from a cyber superpower
- 034B โ The Invisible Infrastructure: Kamatera, Mishayev, Blue-Raman first referenced
- 034C โ The Privacy Empire: Kape Technologies VPN monopoly
- 034D โ The Graduation Pipeline: Unit 8200 โ commercial cyber companies
- 034E โ The Proxy Empire: Bright Data residential proxy network
- 023D โ The VPN Trust Chain: Kape's acquisition trail
- Next: 034G โ The Complete Map: Synthesis of all layers into unified architecture